This led armstrong to conclude that something else must be responsible for making it true that a is f, something else whose existence necessitates that a is f. His work shows how that vision accounts systematically for philosophically difficult phenomena such as properties, laws, truth, the mind and knowledge. This paper argues that a consideration of the problem of providing truthmakers for negative truths undermines truthmaker theory. I agree with him that asking the truthmaker question is a promising way to regiment metaphysical enquiry.
For example, if the sentence kangaroos live in australia is true, then there are kangaroos living in australia. Let me emphasise the high degree of general agreement i have with armstrongs views. Armstrongs analysis, which acknowledges the logical atomism of russell and wittgenstein, makes facts or states of affairs, as the author calls them the fundamental constituents of the world, examining properties, relations, numbers, classes, possibility and necessity. In a clear, evenhanded and nontechnical discussion he makes a compelling case for truthmaking and its. Cameron and others published truth and truthmakers by d.
All truth is a matter of correspondence of a proposition to reality, so truthmaker maximalism should be accepted. Truth and truthmakers cambridge studies in philosophy by d. The metaphysics of truthmaking is one way of approaching the relation. The slogan no truthmaking without truthmakers holds true of. Given his important contributions to the philosophy of mind and metaphysics, david armstrong could be content to merely rehearse these views or even ride off in the philosophical sunset his status. I first learnt to appreciate the power of the notion of a truthmaker from c. A necessary part of david armstrongs account of truthmakers for modal truths is his possibility principle. The notion of a truthmaker is introduced, and the importance of the notion for metaphysics is stressed.
Martin, was not as well formulated in the literature, as the seminal paper by mulligan, simons and smith 1984 had not yet popularised the notion. Advocates of the truthmaker view include armstrong, heil, and cameron. Like the neoclassical view, armstrong endorses a version of the correspondence theory. For keeping truth in truthmaking analysis oxford academic. Philosophy and phenomenological research, 44 1984, 287321. Mellor my metaphysics owes much to david armstrong. The truth 7 is a prime number, for example, is necessitated by the number and the property, a predicative tie is not required p. Find all the books, read about the author, and more.
Truthmaker theory is the branch of metaphysics that explores the relationships between what is true and what exists. A companion to metaphysics 2 edition edited by jaegwon. A truthmaker for a truthbearer is that entity in virtue of which the truthbearer is true. Philosophers call such theories correspondence theories of truth. Truthmakers and the disjunction thesis 77 turning to the case of conjunction, we saw that even ct. Parmenides classic claim that what does not exist cannot be thought. Cambridge university press, may 27, 2004 philosophy 158 pages. It will be widely studied and hotly debated by contemporary analytic metaphysicians. Truthmakers and the groundedness of truth david liggins abstract. Three general commitments drive armstrongs philosophy.
An introduction to truthmakers might hold a belief, but never manifest that belief in behaviour during the whole of a life. Armstrongs theory of truthmaking the most comprehensive source for armstrongs sophisticated theory is his recent book, truth and truthmakers 2004, although the concept of truthmaking was already centrally employed in a previous work by him, a world of states of. Griffith this paper considers three recent attempts by david armstrong, ross cameron, and jonathan schaffer to provide truthmakers for negative existential truths. This chapter argues that a significant class of true synthetic propositions, including inessential predications like the proposition that the rose is red and negative existentials like the proposition that there are no penguins in the north pole are made true by entities, i.
Truthmaking theory, which now has many adherents among contemporary philosophers, is the most recent development of a realist theory of truth, and in this book d. But it isnt generally agreed what that something else might be, or what truthbearers are, or what the character might be of the relationship that holds, if it does, between them, or even whether such a. Thus armstrong holds that to postulate certain truthmakers for certain truths is to admit those truthmakers to ones ontology. Truthmaker theories also offer constraints on theoryontology pairs. Negative truths and truthmaker principles springerlink.
I criticize armstrongs possibility principle for two reasons. A realist theory of truth for a class of sentence holds that there are entities in virtue of which these sentences are true or false. With many adherents among contemporary philosophers, truthmaking theory is the most recent development of a realist theory of truth. In the introduction of his truth and truthmakers, armstrong outlines the. He is well known for his work on metaphysics and the philosophy of mind, and for his defence of a factualist ontology, a functionalist theory of the mind, an externalist epistemology, and a necessitarian conception of the laws of nature. David armstrong is one who does offer a grand vision of the world. Truthmaking and pragmatist conceptions of truth and. Truthmaker theorists claim that for every truth, there is something in virtue of. Lewis and armstrong, given that the putative parts are logically compatible. Armstrong has defended a version of truthmaker necessitarianism, the doctrine that truths necessitate truthmakers. Truth and truthmakers truths are determined not by what we believe, but by the way the world is.
Armstrong offers the first fulllength study of this theory and makes a compelling case for truthmakings importance in philosophy. In this book, armstrong is concerned to explicate the relation between a truth and what makes the truth true. Truth is one of the central subjects in philosophy. Armstrong offers the first fulllength study of this theory. A world of states of affairs cambridge studies in philosophy. David malet armstrong 8 july 1926 may 2014, often d. Available formats pdf please select a format to send. Discussions of truthmakers and truthmaking typically start with the idea that truth depends on being, and not vice versa. Armstrong 2004 and trenton merricks 2007have argued that truthmaker theory requires the existence of propositions. It says nothing about truth, or the truthmaking relation. Since the 2004 book is the most complete account of armstrongs thinking with regard to truthmak.
These are some of the key problems that philosophy should aim to solve. Truthmaker theorists are presented with an uncomfortable dilemma. Martin with a number of arguments of this sort, targeted at ryleanism about dispositions. Ssn 93614x minerva an internet journal of philosophy 9 2005. States of affairs are truthmakers for propositions, though armstrong argues that there may be many such truthmakers for a given proposition, and vice versa. The truth 7 is a prime number, for example, is necessitated by the number and the. Either they must take up the challenge of providing truthmakers for negative truths, or else they must explain why negative truths are exceptions to the principle. This paper introduces, explains, and defends a theory of truth and truthmakers constituted by the following four claims. Truthmaker necessitarianism, he contends, requires the postulation of totality facts, which serve as. Truthmaking theory, which now has many adherents among contemporary philosophers, is a recent development of a realist theory of truth, and in this book, first published in 2004, d.
Philosophers have speculated on the question whether every truthbearer requires a truthmaker. We call such entities truthmakers and contend that those for a wide range of sentences about the real world are moments dependent particulars. A survey of the arguments i was introduced to then should serve as. So armstrongs naturalism commits him to denying that the truthmaking relation is internal after all.
Armstrongs theory of partial identity and the theory of moments, i. In 1997, david armstrong argued that the world is a world of states of affairs. But it isnt generally agreed what that something else might be, or what truth bearers are, or what the character might be of the relationship that holds, if it does, between them, or even whether such a. But according to the truthmaker principle every truth has a truthmaker. Armstrongs latest book, truth and truthmakers, is a formidable yet compact treatise on the metaphysics of truthmaking. In my view, no claim is trivial if it entails something. In his latest book, truth and truthmakers, he remains strongly committed to. A collection of facts, opinions and comments from survivors of. In that case, the counterparts of the world under the evoked counterpart relation are many and varied. Tahko armstrongontruthmakingandrealism 1 introduction thetitleofthispaperre. Truthmaker theory internet encyclopedia of philosophy. These three treatments of truthmakers venture to characterize truthmakers only for atomic sentences or propositions.
1239 904 1029 301 229 769 299 137 1025 467 794 929 1085 790 227 202 1219 1272 888 693 607 783 833 883 323 535 1421 226 1149 141 404 36 979 824 653 331 630 1136 565 991 608 1380 623 901 174 1196 43